| Platinum | Golden Boot Cafe |
| Gold | Famoso Neapolitan Pizzeria |
| Silver | That Place Restaurant |
| Bronze | Henry's Kitchen Pasta & Grill (Reservation Only) |
| Top Pick | Doppio Zero Pizza |
| Top Pick | Emilio Finatti Pizzeria Poco |
| Top Pick | Old Spaghetti Factory Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Pasta Polo |
| Top Pick | Piva Modern Italian |
| Top Pick | Pizza Factory |