| Platinum | Famoso Neapolitan Pizzeria |
| Platinum | Spacca Napoli |
| Gold | Mama Said Pizza |
| Silver | Pappa Leo's Pizza |
| Bronze | La Ruota Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Green Olive Pizza |
| Top Pick | Me-N-Ed's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pasta Polo |
| Top Pick | Plateau Pizza |
| Top Pick | Sunfire Pizzeria |